The controlled drinking model has some significant flaws for the many who are desperate for help. As an addiction specialist counselor, I have had the opportunity to work with many individuals struggling with alcohol abuse and addiction. One of the models that I have encountered in my practice is the controlled drinking model. This model suggests that you can learn to drink in moderation and regain control over your drinking behaviour.
On the surface, the controlled drinking model seems like a reasonable approach, after all, the goal of treatment is to help individuals regain control over their lives and their behaviour.
However, upon closer examination, its flaws, unfortunately, make it an inappropriate approach for many individuals struggling with abuse and addiction issues.
First, the controlled drinking model assumes that all individuals have the same level of tolerance and that they can all learn to drink in moderation. However, this is not the case. Alcohol addiction is a complex disorder that affects individuals differently. Some individuals may be able to learn to drink in moderation, while others may not be able to control their drinking behavior no matter how hard they try.
Second, the controlled drinking model ignores the fact that substance abuse is a chronic condition in many individuals that requires ongoing management. Just because an individual is able to achieve a period of moderation, it does not mean that they will be able to maintain it long-term. Relapse is common and the controlled drinking model does not provide the necessary support and resources to help individuals maintain their goals.
The model does not address the underlying issues that drive problematic drinking behaviours. It focuses solely on the behaviour itself, rather than the underlying causes and motivations that led to the development of the abuse or addiction. Alcohol addiction is often the result of deeper emotional or psychological issues such as trauma, stress, anxiety, depression, and other mental health disorders. Without addressing these underlying issues, individuals are at a higher risk of relapse and may continue to struggle.
Additionally, the controlled drinking model does not address the social and environmental factors that contribute to alcohol addiction. These factors may include a lack of support from friends and family, financial stress, job loss, or other life changes. Understanding these factors is crucial in order to provide targeted and effective treatment.
In short, the controlled drinking model is limited in its ability to effectively address the complex issues that drive disfunctional alcohol use. It is important for anyone calling themselves an addiction specialist to take a holistic, comprehensive approach that addresses the underlying causes and motivations, as well as the social and environmental factors that contribute to alcohol addiction. This approach will ensure that individuals are more likely to achieve and maintain long-term recovery.
In conclusion, while the controlled drinking model may be appropriate for some individuals, it is not a one-size-fits-all approach. It is important for addiction specialists to take into account the individual needs and circumstances of each person they are working with when developing a treatment plan. A comprehensive, holistic approach that addresses all factors is always necessary for effective treatment.
Comments